Supergirl: A Familiar Tone in the DC Universe?

The upcoming "Supergirl" film, a key follow-up to the recently launched "Superman" in the revitalized DC Universe, has unveiled its first trailer, sparking discussions about its stylistic direction. Directed by Craig Gillespie, known for "Cruella" and "I, Tonya," the preview indicates a surprising tonal alignment with James Gunn's earlier "Guardians of the Galaxy" trilogy for Marvel, rather than a direct continuation of the "Superman" film's distinct approach.

This stylistic similarity is evident in several aspects, including the trailer's choice of a rock-and-roll soundtrack—featuring Blondie's "Call Me"—and its predominantly space-faring setting, complete with what appear to be space pirates reminiscent of the Ravagers. While Gunn's "Superman" offered a fresh, optimistic take on the superhero genre, differing from expectations based on his prior work, "Supergirl" seems to revert to a more familiar, action-oriented, and perhaps even cynical tone. The heroine's line, "He sees the good in people. I see the truth," followed by a scene of her wielding a mace-like weapon, underscores this darker perspective, setting her apart from her more idealistic cousin.

Despite James Gunn's stated commitment to allowing each DCU project to develop its own unique creative voice, rather than enforcing a uniform cinematic style akin to past superhero franchises, the "Supergirl" trailer raises questions. The striking resemblance to his previous Marvel films could suggest either Gillespie's interpretation of a "James Gunn-style" movie or a subconscious return to Gunn's signature elements. This development, occurring just two films into the new DCU, has led some to wonder if the franchise might inadvertently be repeating certain creative patterns. The hope remains that upon its release in summer 2026, "Supergirl" will ultimately carve out its own distinctive niche within the superhero genre.

The film's exploration of a hero who confronts a harsher reality, coupled with a commitment to individuality in storytelling, can inspire audiences to embrace complexity and truth in their own lives, rather than shying away from difficult observations. It encourages a balanced view, acknowledging that while optimism is powerful, understanding the 'truth' is equally crucial for genuine heroism and personal growth.