Elderly Man Convicted of Extensive Theft and Money Laundering in Door County

Feb 27, 2025 at 6:00 PM

An 81-year-old resident from the Town of Nasewaupee, Dale Forrest Pautsch, has been found guilty on 15 felony charges related to business theft and money laundering. The verdict was delivered by the Door County Circuit Court on February 12. Over a period of ten months, law enforcement agencies uncovered an extensive scheme involving multiple victims and significant financial losses. Authorities identified 23 individuals who collectively lost over $1.1 million. This case highlights the complexity of modern financial crimes and the thorough investigative efforts required to bring perpetrators to justice.

Law enforcement officials, including the Door County Sheriff’s Office and the Sturgeon Bay Police Department, conducted an exhaustive investigation into Pautsch's activities. The probe began in June 2024 when Pautsch was initially arrested. Throughout the investigation, authorities executed seven search warrants and issued four subpoenas. These actions led to the seizure of various assets belonging to Pautsch, including a business in Gardner, residential properties in Nasewaupee, two vehicles, a UTV, jewelry, and approximately $160,000 in cash.

The authorities meticulously documented the extent of Pautsch's operations, revealing a sophisticated network of illegal activities. The seized assets are now being processed for liquidation under an agreement with the court. The proceeds from these sales will be directed toward compensating the victims. This approach aims to provide some form of restitution to those affected by Pautsch's actions.

Pautsch remains incarcerated at the Door County Jail as he awaits his sentencing. The court has scheduled the sentencing hearing for May 29 at 1 pm in Door County Circuit Court Branch I. This case underscores the importance of vigilant law enforcement and the need for robust measures to combat financial crimes.