Robert Forgione poses a crucial question about Schoen's potential to fire his good friend Daboll based on Mara's demand for a change. Additionally, the difficulty of attracting a new defensive coordinator if Bowen is released is also discussed. This situation raises concerns about the stability and future direction of the team.
Unraveling the Giants' Coaching and Draft Dilemmas
Coaching Dilemma
Robert Forgione inquires whether Schoen would fire Daboll if Mara insists on a change. Ed responds that Schoen would likely sign off on firing Daboll as he values his own job more. It is also noted that the defensive coordinator pool might be limited due to Daboll's status and the frequent changes in the position.
Brian Misdom questions why Schoen seems "safer" to keep his job despite the Giants' record. Ed explains that both Schoen and Daboll have made mistakes, but firing the GM would involve blowing up the entire organization. He provides examples of other general managers who succeeded after rocky starts.
Draft and Free Agency Considerations
Jeff Bergman wonders how the Giants can attract a quality coaching candidate if Schoen has only one year left on his contract. Ed clarifies that he is not certain about Schoen's contract length but suggests that both Daboll and Schoen have two years left if they were hired in the same cycle. He also discusses the importance of trust and a good working relationship between the GM and head coach.
Jason Sorley asks about prioritizing players in free agency before the draft. Ed responds that it is too early to make such decisions and that the GM and coach will play a role in the assessment.
Quarterback Options
Jon Joel asks about the Giants signing Daniel Jones as a bridge quarterback. Ed firmly states that it is not a good idea as there is no chance Jones would do it.
Andrew Greene considers getting Kirk Cousins as a placeholder quarterback while rebuilding. Ed agrees that Cousins would be on the list but suggests offering only a couple of Day 3 picks in a trade.
Draft Strategies
Keith Nersten expresses his preference for trading down and getting more draft picks. Ed warns against committing to specific positions in the draft and emphasizes picking based on available players.
David Silver questions the rankings of Kayvon Thibodeaux, John Michael Schmitz, and Josh Ezeudu in their draft classes. Ed explains that teams draft based on the information they have at the time and that players' performances can vary from expectations.
Evaluating Quarterbacks
John Foti discusses the importance of loving a quarterback when drafting. Ed emphasizes that physical traits cannot be changed, but quarterbacks can learn to see the field better and make better decisions.
Rooting for the Team
Dennis Norton wonders whether to root for the Giants to win in the last game of the year. Ed believes it is an individual decision and that it is enjoyable to beat the Eagles and potentially get a better draft pick.
Ownership's Responsibility
Albert Juliano questions why the Maras are given a free pass for the team's years of futility. Ed responds that ownership is ultimately responsible but that they do care about winning and that it is not realistic to expect them to sell the team.
