The state of Utah has maintained a law for 25 years that prevents car dealerships from being open on both Saturday and Sunday. Recently, there was an attempt to modify this regulation through SB136 by Senator Stephanie Pitcher, who believes the government should not dictate business hours. However, facing significant opposition, she decided not to proceed with the bill. This legislation originated in 2000, championed by businessman Larry H. Miller, who advocated for a six-day work cycle. The debate highlights concerns about employee well-being and business flexibility.

Origins and Support for the Existing Regulation

This law, introduced two and a half decades ago, was initially backed by prominent figures in the automotive industry. It mandates that dealerships must remain closed on one day during the weekend. Supporters argue that this measure benefits employees and their families by ensuring they have a day off. Craig Bickmore, representing New Car Dealers of Utah, emphasized the positive impact on staff welfare. He also expressed concerns that altering the law could lead to increased working hours for employees, as businesses might feel pressured to stay open on Sundays.

In 2000, the late businessman Larry H. Miller led the campaign for this legislation, advocating for a six-day work cycle. According to Bickmore, requiring dealerships to close on either Saturday or Sunday promotes a healthier work-life balance for employees. Senate Majority Whip Chris Wilson, a car dealership owner himself, echoed these sentiments. He warned that if the law were changed, it would compel dealerships to operate on Sundays, potentially overburdening the current workforce. Wilson stressed that hiring additional staff is not feasible, leading to longer working hours for existing employees.

Challenges and Opposition to Changing the Law

Senator Stephanie Pitcher questioned the rationale behind specific regulations for car dealerships while other industries are not subject to similar constraints. Despite her reservations, she chose not to pursue SB136 further due to strong opposition. Pitcher remains committed to the principle that businesses should have the autonomy to decide their operating hours without governmental interference. She plans to monitor related legislation concerning mandatory Sunday closures in other sectors.

Pitcher, who has served in the Legislature since 2019, finds the existing law somewhat peculiar. She argued that the government should not impose restrictions on when businesses can operate. Her stance reflects a broader debate about the role of government in regulating private enterprise. Although she decided not to move forward with the bill, Pitcher maintains that businesses should have the freedom to choose their operating days. She will continue to observe similar legislative efforts in the House of Representatives, which address the issue of required Sunday closures for various industries. Ultimately, Pitcher believes that businesses should have the authority to determine their own schedules without external mandates.