Unfinished Meals: A Rising Trend in New York's Dining Scene

Mar 18, 2025 at 4:22 PM

In the bustling dining landscape of Manhattan, restaurateurs like Emmett Burke are witnessing a peculiar trend. Patrons at his two Chicago-style pizzerias increasingly leave behind partially eaten pizzas without requesting boxes for leftovers. This behavior is not unique to Burke's establishments but extends across various eateries in New York and other cities. Experts attribute this shift to changing social norms, the convenience of takeout, and evolving attitudes toward food sharing post-pandemic. According to ReFED, an organization focused on reducing food waste, Americans discard an average of 53 pounds or $329 worth of uneaten restaurant meals annually. While quantifying changes over time remains challenging, anecdotal evidence suggests a notable shift in diner perceptions regarding leftovers.

Emmett Burke, owner of Emmett’s and Emmett’s on Grove, has observed this phenomenon firsthand. He notes that diners appear less inclined to request containers for their leftover slices. Instead, plates return to the kitchen with significant portions untouched, prompting him to question whether something might be amiss with the food itself. However, he acknowledges that many customers simply do not value taking home uneaten portions. This observation aligns with broader trends reported by other restaurateurs who notice similar patterns among their clientele.

Experts suggest several reasons behind this growing aversion to doggy bags. Social stigma surrounding leftovers plays a role, as some individuals view them as unappealing or unnecessary. Additionally, the ease of ordering fresh meals through delivery services diminishes the appeal of saving uneaten dishes for later consumption. Furthermore, following the pandemic-induced hiatus from communal eating practices, there seems to be a resurgence in shared dining experiences where people finish meals together rather than preserving remnants for future use.

ReFED President Dana Gunders highlights another perspective: some individuals categorically reject eating leftovers based on personal principles. Despite these evolving attitudes, organizations committed to combating food waste plan further investigations into this issue. Understanding why consumers increasingly abandon unfinished meals could inform strategies aimed at reducing unnecessary discards within the hospitality industry while promoting sustainable dining habits.

This emerging trend raises important questions about consumer behavior and its impact on food waste. As restaurants adapt to shifting preferences, fostering awareness around responsible dining choices becomes crucial. Encouraging patrons to embrace sustainable practices such as packing leftovers or ordering appropriate portion sizes can help mitigate environmental concerns associated with excessive food disposal. Ultimately, addressing this behavioral shift requires collaboration between businesses, policymakers, and communities dedicated to creating a more conscientious approach towards dining experiences.