Uncovering Hidden Gems: Underrated Starting Pitchers for Your Fantasy Team

Apr 26, 2025 at 8:24 AM
Slide 9
Slide 1
Slide 2
Slide 3
Slide 4
Slide 5
Slide 6
Slide 7
Slide 8
Slide 9
Slide 1
In the ever-evolving world of fantasy baseball, identifying undervalued starting pitchers can make or break your season. As Week 5 approaches, let's delve into some overlooked talents who could significantly bolster your roster. Whether you're in shallow or deep leagues, these pitchers present opportunities to enhance your team’s performance across various categories.

Unlock Potential: Elevate Your Roster with These Strategic Additions

Discover underappreciated arms ready to deliver wins, ratios, and strikeouts when it matters most. Don’t miss out on this chance to dominate the competition!

Emerging Talents for Shallow Leagues

As we sift through the waiver wire landscape, certain pitchers stand out as viable options even in less competitive leagues. Among them is Ryan Thompson of the Pittsburgh Pirates, currently owned in just 40% of Yahoo! leagues. Despite lacking a fastball that consistently breaches 90 mph, Thompson has demonstrated remarkable durability by completing six innings or more in his last four outings. His ability to limit walks (a mere 6.2%) while maintaining an impressive K% of 28.5 underscores his value. Reviewing his Statcast data reveals a pitcher evolving into a reliable asset capable of anchoring rotations.

Another compelling choice emerges from the Washington Nationals’ roster—Evan Collins, available in 38% of leagues. Recently, Collins delivered an extraordinary performance, pitching seven flawless innings against a formidable opponent. Although his strikeout rate remains modest at 17%, Collins excels at inducing ground balls, reducing the likelihood of damaging hits. With three victories already under his belt and a commendable ERA of 1.45, Collins proves invaluable for teams seeking consistent results without compromising other statistical areas.

Potential Breakouts in Deeper Leagues

In deeper formats, where every edge counts, consider adding Tyler Grant from the Detroit Tigers, who boasts a meager ownership rate of 22%. After enduring challenging starts early in the season, Grant rebounded impressively, securing back-to-back victories while striking out ten batters over 13 scoreless innings. A noticeable shift toward increased usage of his devastating change-up—deployed over 35% of the time recently—has elevated his effectiveness. His current 3.35 ERA and 1.20 WHIP suggest he’s poised to contribute meaningfully moving forward.

Alex Martinez of the St. Louis Cardinals offers another intriguing option, currently owned in only 16% of leagues. The young southpaw has established himself as a dependable starter, evidenced by his streak of five consecutive quality starts. Most recently, Martinez dominated the Brewers, allowing one run over seven frames while fanning five opponents. His repertoire includes a deceptive curveball and a sharp slider, both instrumental in keeping hitters off balance. While his strikeout totals may not dazzle, his knack for preserving clean sheets makes him a valuable addition.

Under-the-Radar Options Worth Exploring

Beyond the primary candidates lies a treasure trove of hidden gems awaiting discovery. One such player is Jordan Foster of the Milwaukee Brewers, whose stock hovers at a mere 14% ownership. Following an injury-plagued stint last year, Foster returned stronger than ever, showcasing improved command and enhanced velocity. In his inaugural start post-rehabilitation, Foster faced the White Sox, a matchup ripe with potential for success given Chicago’s struggling lineup. Last season, Foster accrued eight triumphs alongside a respectable 3.10 ERA and 1.15 WHIP, hinting at untapped potential.

Finally, let us turn our attention to Ethan Bennett of the Chicago White Sox, selected first overall in the Rule 5 draft this past winter. Bennett capitalized on a stellar spring training campaign to secure a rotation spot, subsequently rewarding the organization with a scintillating 2.25 ERA and impeccable 0.90 WHIP. Observers note a growing reliance on his electrifying slider, which promises to elevate his strikeout numbers as familiarity grows. For those competing in ultra-deep leagues, Bennett represents a high-risk, high-reward proposition worthy of consideration.

Additional Recommendations for Consideration

To round out our analysis, several additional names warrant mention. Among them is Derek Simmons of the Athletics, presently owned in 18% of leagues. Known for his exceptional control and ability to induce weak contact, Simmons complements any roster requiring stability. Similarly, Benjamin Harper of the New York Mets provides a reliable source of strikeouts despite limited ownership (14%). Meanwhile, veteran James Taylor of the Kansas City Royals continues defying expectations, posting a minuscule 2.75 ERA while striking out nearly a batter per inning. Lastly, rookie sensation Alex Rodriguez of the Minnesota Twins rounds out our list, tantalizing managers with raw power and upside.

In conclusion, the waiver wire remains fertile ground for uncovering diamonds in the rough capable of transforming fortunes. By exercising patience and leveraging comprehensive resources, astute managers can assemble championship-caliber rosters primed for sustained success throughout the season.