Costco's food court has long been celebrated for its budget-friendly offerings, with the iconic hot dog and soda combo remaining at $1.50 since 1984. Among the beloved treats, churros held a special place in customers' hearts. However, these cinnamon-sugar delights have faced several changes over the years, including their temporary disappearance during the pandemic and eventual replacement with a giant chocolate chip cookie. This article explores why the churros vanished and how enthusiasts can find satisfying alternatives.

The Disappearance of a Beloved Treat

The journey of Costco's churros began as a staple menu item, priced at just $1. Despite their popularity, they were removed from the menu during the pandemic, much to the dismay of loyal fans. When churros returned in 2021, they came back with a twist—literally. These new "twisted" churros didn't last long, and by early 2024, churros vanished entirely, replaced by a giant chocolate chip cookie. The reasons behind this change remain unclear, leaving many wondering what led to this decision.

For years, churros were a cherished part of the Costco experience. Customers enjoyed the traditional straight churros coated in cinnamon sugar. Their removal during the pandemic was unexpected, but even more surprising was their brief return in a twisted form. This version didn't gain the same traction as its predecessor and was soon phased out. The space left by churros on the menu was filled with a giant chocolate chip cookie, priced higher than the original treat. Fans speculate that supply chain issues or changing consumer preferences might have influenced this shift.

Searching for a Suitable Replacement

Fans of Costco's churros have not given up on finding a suitable substitute. Many have turned to frozen options from brands like Tio Pepes, available in bulk at Walmart or Amazon. However, these come in large quantities, requiring ample freezer space. A more convenient solution was found at local grocery stores, where Goya brand frozen churros are available. These can be easily prepared at home, providing a close match to the original taste.

Another surprising source emerged in the form of Subway's new Footlong menu, which includes oversized churros. While these cost twice as much as the original Costco churros, they offer a similar experience in terms of size and flavor. The quest for a perfect substitute has led many to explore various options, from frozen varieties to unexpected sources like Subway. Ultimately, while no replacement can fully replicate the original, these alternatives provide a way to satisfy those sweet cravings when a Costco churro craving strikes.