Newegg Faces 'Worthless' Label and Short Bet from Martin Shkreli Amidst Meme Stock Frenzy

Aug 15, 2025 at 5:15 AM
Single Slide

This report details the recent market movements surrounding Newegg Commerce Inc. and the surprising intervention of Martin Shkreli. Despite Newegg's significant stock surge, Shkreli, a figure known for his contentious past in the pharmaceutical industry, has publicly declared a short position, citing the company's underlying lack of value. This situation encapsulates the ongoing tension between market fundamentals and the unpredictable influence of 'meme stock' phenomena, where social media sentiment can dramatically inflate stock prices beyond traditional financial logic.

\n

Market Disruption: Shkreli's Bearish Stance on Newegg

\n

On a recent Thursday, the financial world witnessed a notable development as former hedge fund manager Martin Shkreli, often referred to as \"Pharma Bro,\" announced his decision to short Newegg Commerce Inc. This move comes on the heels of an astonishing 1,338% surge in the e-commerce retailer's stock value earlier this year. Shkreli conveyed his pessimistic outlook through social media, labeling the online retail giant as fundamentally overvalued and \"close to worthless,\" particularly highlighting its meager 12% gross margins even during favorable periods. He contended that even in an ideal scenario with zero operational costs, the company's valuation would still be inflated, implying that after accounting for the essential expenditures of running a business, the stock's true worth might only be around $50 per share.

\n

The dramatic escalation in Newegg's stock price, which saw an increase of over 1,500% within a mere three months, is largely attributed to a resurgence of interest in meme stocks. Data from Benzinga Pro indicates that approximately 12.25% of Newegg's float is currently sold short, underscoring significant investor skepticism despite the upward trend. Further contributing to investor enthusiasm, on July 15, Newegg revealed its intentions to offer up to $65 million in common stock, a disclosure that preceded a remarkable 260% increase in share price.

\n

As of the market close on Thursday, Newegg's stock stood at $128.09, marking an impressive 39.39% gain, with after-hours trading pushing it slightly higher to $128.86. The stock's trading range over the past 52 weeks has been exceptionally wide, from a low of $3.32 to a high of $133.00, reflecting its volatile journey. The company commands a market capitalization of $2.50 billion, with an average daily trading volume of 1.18 million shares.

\n

From a technical analysis perspective, Newegg's shares reached new 52-week highs on Thursday, supported by a robust trading volume of 1.36 million shares, significantly surpassing its 100-day average. The stock exhibits strong momentum, evidenced by a Benzinga Edge Stock Ranking momentum score of 99.49. However, the Relative Strength Index (RSI) currently sits at 80.7, a figure that typically signals overbought conditions and suggests a potential for a market correction or pullback in the near future.

\n

The unfolding narrative of Newegg, juxtaposed with Shkreli's bold short position, serves as a compelling reminder of the dual forces at play in contemporary financial markets. On one side, we observe the power of collective investor sentiment, often amplified by digital platforms, capable of driving asset prices to unprecedented heights. On the other, the enduring principles of fundamental analysis, championed by figures like Shkreli, insist on an intrinsic value based on financial health and operational efficiency. This dichotomy poses a profound question for both seasoned investors and casual observers: where does the true value lie in an era where market narratives can be as influential as balance sheets? The outcome of Shkreli's bet against Newegg could provide a significant lesson on the sustainability of meme-driven rallies versus the eventual gravity of economic realities.