Throughout the decades, the New Jersey Hambletonian has witnessed numerous thrilling finishes. Since 1981, this prestigious event has seen many horses come tantalizingly close to victory. One of the most memorable moments occurred in 1981 when Super Juan narrowly missed out on the top spot, finishing second to Shiaway St Pat. This marked the beginning of a series of intense races where the margin between first and second was often razor-thin. Over the years, trainers like Howard Beissinger and drivers such as John Campbell have been at the heart of these nail-biting moments. The 1983 race saw Joie De Vie not only secure a significant second-place finish but also become the first trotter to surpass $1 million in earnings within a single year, highlighting the financial stakes involved in this competition.

The late 20th century brought more drama to the Hambletonian. In 1989, Park Avenue Joe and Probe created an unforgettable dead-heat finish, showcasing two first-time winners in Ron Waples and Bill Fahy. However, their success did not carry over to the Breeders Crown later that year. The 1990s introduced new champions and familiar faces, with Embassy Lobell's second-place finish in 1990 setting the stage for a decade of competitive racing. Pine Chip’s runner-up position in 1993 was particularly noteworthy, as he went on to be named Trotter of the Year twice and sire back-to-back Hambletonian winners in 2001 and 2002. Jimmy Takter's influence grew stronger during this period, culminating in his stablemates Take Chances and Malabar Man taking the top two spots in 1997.

The Hambletonian continues to captivate audiences with its blend of tradition and excitement. From the early 2000s to the present day, each race has added a unique chapter to the event's storied history. The 2023 contest, featuring Highland Kismet's valiant effort against Karl in challenging weather conditions, exemplifies the spirit of perseverance and determination that defines this classic race. These close calls remind us of the resilience and dedication required in the world of horse racing. Each runner-up story is a testament to the hard work and passion behind every participant, reinforcing the importance of striving for excellence even in the face of adversity.