Joyride Thief Repeatedly Steals and Returns Victim's Car, Leaving Trail of Drugs

In a bizarre case of repeated vehicle theft and return, a Stafford County, Virginia man found himself the victim of a joyride thief who would take his car only to bring it back hours later, leaving the owner perplexed and law enforcement on high alert.

Unbelievable Twists and Turns in a Perplexing Car Theft Case

Disappearing and Reappearing Car Leaves Owner Baffled

The saga began on October 6th when David Basye, a Honda Insight owner, reported his car missing to the Stafford County Sheriff's Office. Basye was initially under the impression that his vehicle had been towed, but the mystery deepened when the car mysteriously reappeared in the same spot just hours later, with nothing stolen from inside.

Thief Strikes Again, Sparking a Foot Chase

The bizarre pattern continued the following Tuesday, when Basye noticed his car had been stolen again around 2 a.m. This time, the thief returned the vehicle an hour later, leading to a foot chase between Basye and the suspect. The chase ended with the suspect escaping, leaving Basye even more confused about the repeated thefts and returns.

Surveillance Cameras Capture the Culprit

Determined to get to the bottom of the mystery, Basye installed home surveillance cameras, which paid off on October 16th when the system spotted the car leaving once again. Alerted authorities were quick to respond, apprehending the driver, identified as G'avontai Mul-Key, 22, of Stafford.

Drugs and Driving Violations Uncovered

During the arrest, Mul-Key was found to be in possession of blue fentanyl pills, which he had allegedly left behind while attempting to flee. The passenger, Carlos Shutts, 21, also of Stafford, was discovered to be in possession of additional controlled substances.

Charges and Consequences for the Joyride Thieves

Mul-Key was charged with a slew of offenses, including two counts of unauthorized use of a vehicle, grand larceny, felony eluding, obstruction of justice, possession of controlled substances, driving without a license, and a traffic lane violation. He was held at Rappahannock Regional Jail without bond. Shutts was charged with possession of controlled substances and felony by a prisoner, and was held on a $3,000 secured bond.The case serves as a stark reminder of the unpredictable and often bizarre nature of criminal behavior, as well as the importance of vigilance and the use of technology in combating such incidents. The repeated thefts and returns, coupled with the discovery of drugs, have left the community and law enforcement alike grappling with the complexities of this perplexing car theft case.