Is this a mountain? A multistorey car park? Or both? Inside Shanghai’s audacious £225m summit

Sep 30, 2024 at 4:00 AM

Reshaping the Skyline: Shanghai's Artificial Mountain Marvels

China's relentless pursuit of urban expansion has led to the transformation of its landscape, with authorities often resorting to drastic measures to reshape the terrain. However, Shanghai, the country's financial hub, has taken a unique approach, embracing the creation of artificial mountains to enhance the city's aesthetic appeal and provide recreational opportunities for its residents.

Unlocking the Secrets of Shanghai's Engineered Peaks

Conquering the Impossible: The Twin Hills of Shanghai

Shanghai's Twin Hills, also known as the "Nipple Mountains," are a testament to the city's ambition and engineering prowess. This 2.1 billion yuan (£225 million) project, seven years in the making, has transformed a former industrial landscape into a meticulously landscaped oasis, complete with two peaks reaching 37 and 48 meters in height. Designed by the French landscape architecture firm Agence Ter, the hills are adorned with over 7,000 trees, winding trails, and a cascading waterfall, all built atop a massive multi-story car park.The inspiration for the Twin Hills came from the Chinese conception of landscape, where the interplay of mountains and water, known as "shan shui," is deeply revered. The architects sought to incorporate these elements into their design, creating a harmonious blend of natural and man-made features. The project's nine peaks and three streams, culminating in a reflective lake, are a nod to the historic Songjiang district, the cultural birthplace of Shanghai.However, the construction of the Twin Hills was not without its challenges. The swampy terrain and risk of landslides in the seismic zone required the use of 6,000 piles and over 30,000 tons of steel and concrete to create a sturdy foundation. The result is a marvel of engineering, where the hills' slopes are reinforced with hefty concrete retaining walls, each packed with soil and topped with lush vegetation.

Heatherwick's Verdant Mounds: Tian'an Sunshine Plaza

The Twin Hills are not the only artificial mountains in Shanghai's landscape. Five miles across town, the Tian'an Sunshine Plaza, designed by renowned architect Thomas Heatherwick, features two tree-covered mounds rising 60 and 100 meters high. This colossal shopping mall complex, with its mountain-like appearance, was intended to bring a touch of sylvan magic to a district that previously lacked a distinct identity.However, the ecological impact of these artificial mountains has been a subject of debate. Experts estimate that it would take around 155 years for the trees planted on the Tian'an Sunshine Plaza's concrete planters to offset the carbon emitted during the construction process. The trees, imprisoned in their elevated perches, do not appear to be thriving, raising questions about the sustainability and environmental implications of such ambitious projects.

Shangqing Garden: A Cliffside Illusion

Further south, in the bustling intersection of Changde and Changshou roads, stands an even more striking example of Shanghai's artificial mountain-building efforts. The Shangqing Garden apartment complex, built in 2003, appears to emerge from a 50-meter-high craggy escarpment, creating the illusion of a high-rise stack of modern cave dwellings.This unique architectural feature, driven by the principles of feng shui, is meant to moderate the "ferocious location" of the busy junction. While some residents have embraced the project's distinctive character, the reality is that the mighty rock wall is little more than a brittle fibreglass shell, with cracks and holes beginning to appear, shattering the illusion.

Balancing Ambition and Sustainability

Shanghai's artificial mountain projects, while showcasing the city's engineering prowess and design aspirations, have also raised concerns about their environmental impact and long-term sustainability. The carbon footprint of these endeavors, the challenges of maintaining the artificial landscapes, and the potential risks posed by the structures themselves are all factors that must be carefully considered as Shanghai continues to reshape its skyline.As the city's authorities and urban planners navigate the delicate balance between ambition and sustainability, the future of Shanghai's artificial mountain marvels remains a topic of ongoing discussion and debate. The city's ability to strike this balance will ultimately determine the lasting impact and legacy of these remarkable feats of engineering and design.