Insights from the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine: Evaluators Share Their Thoughts

Mar 3, 2025 at 4:57 AM

The conclusion of the NFL scouting combine in Indianapolis has left coaches, executives, and scouts with a wealth of information to digest. Beyond physical measurements and drill results, interviews and informal exchanges have provided deeper insights into the prospects' character and potential.

One of the most discussed topics was the comparison between two top quarterback prospects, Shedeur Sanders and Cam Ward. Opinions varied widely on their readiness for the NFL. While some evaluators praised Sanders for his sharp throwing skills and confident demeanor, likening him to a modern-day Tom Brady, others favored Ward’s leadership qualities and consistency across multiple college programs. An NFC executive highlighted Ward’s exceptional personality and leadership, believing these traits would help him refine any minor technical issues. Conversely, an assistant coach saw both quarterbacks as viable starters, emphasizing Sanders’ toughness and ability to play to his strengths.

In addition to quarterbacks, concerns about Abdul Carter's medical status raised questions about his draft position. Despite a stress reaction in his right foot, doctors confirmed that Carter wouldn’t need surgery and could still participate in workouts. A talent evaluator suggested that Carter’s potential long-term value outweighs any short-term setbacks, especially for teams drafting early who can afford to ease him into the lineup. This perspective underscores the importance of projecting a player’s four-year impact rather than focusing solely on immediate contributions.

The versatility of Travis Hunter, a receiver and defensive back from Colorado, sparked debate among evaluators. Some believed his dual-role potential justified a high draft pick, while others argued he should focus on one position. An AFC evaluator suggested that if Hunter were to play both sides, he should primarily be a cornerback with limited offensive snaps. The complexity of game planning and film study at the pro level made it unlikely for him to excel in both roles simultaneously. However, there was consensus on his extraordinary talent, with one executive noting that such duality is extremely rare.

The running back market also presented unexpected nuances. While Boise State’s Ashton Jeanty and North Carolina’s Omarion Hampton were projected to be drafted in the first round, opinions diverged on their relative strengths. Jeanty’s explosiveness and balance impressed some, but his size raised concerns. Hampton, meanwhile, was compared favorably to Cleveland Browns’ Nick Chubb for his tenacity and agility. Another name worth watching is Georgia’s Trevor Etienne, whose well-rounded skill set, despite his smaller stature, earned praise from evaluators.

Finally, Alabama’s Jalen Milroe emerged as a quarterback prospect with immense upside. Though his raw passing skills are inconsistent, his athletic prowess makes him a valuable asset. One executive likened him to Taysom Hill on steroids, suggesting he could contribute in various ways beyond quarterbacking. The key to maximizing Milroe’s potential lies in patience and a structured development plan, much like cooking a meal that requires careful timing and attention.

The NFL scouting combine not only showcases physical talents but also provides invaluable insights into the character and adaptability of future stars. As teams weigh their options, the emphasis on long-term potential and versatile skill sets will guide their decisions, ensuring they invest wisely in the next generation of football talent.