Europe’s Stock Leaders Are Fading in Bad Sign for Future Returns

Sep 14, 2024 at 7:00 AM

Navigating the Shifting Sands of European Equities: Adapting to a New Landscape

The once-robust engines powering Europe's stock market gains are losing steam, leaving the region's equities facing a void at a time when concerns over slowing growth and geopolitical tensions are testing investor confidence. As the market's former darlings fade, investors are scrambling to find the next wave of opportunities, with sectors like healthcare, utilities, and banks emerging as potential frontrunners in the race for market leadership.

Unlocking the Secrets of Europe's Evolving Equity Landscape

The Fading Dominance of Europe's Powerhouses

The luxury sector, led by the likes of LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton SE, has tumbled over the past six months, along with the automotive industry. More recently, healthcare heavyweights such as Novo Nordisk A/S and tech leaders like ASML Holding NV have also slid from their peaks. With no obvious candidates to take the baton, the region's equity performance has been left exposed, leaving investors searching for the next wave of market drivers.

The Shifting Tides of Investor Sentiment

The changing landscape is evident in the stark contrast between the flows into Europe-focused funds and ETFs, which have seen billions of dollars in withdrawals, and the large amounts being pumped into US and international equity funds. This shift in investor sentiment reflects the fact that the main drivers of the region's gains have fallen behind the performance of America's Magnificent Seven group of tech companies.

The Cyclical Nature of the European Market

The European market is inherently more cyclical than its US counterpart, with economically-sensitive sectors accounting for about two-thirds of the benchmark Stoxx 600. This high correlation to these sectors means that any support from these firms is now at risk, as they face a double blow from slowing growth and trade risks with China.

The China Factor and Its Impact on Europe

Europe's greater reliance on Chinese demand, with firms getting about 8% of their revenues from the Asian country, compared to just 2% for S&P 500 peers, makes the region more vulnerable to the ripple effects of China's economic challenges. This includes the impact on oil prices, which have fallen to lows not seen since 2021, affecting Europe's energy heavyweights such as BP Plc, Shell Plc, and TotalEnergies SE.

The Defensive Shift and Its Implications

As the market's former leaders falter, investors are heavily rotating their portfolios, seeking new opportunities. The defensive bias towards sectors like healthcare and consumer staples, which account for more than 30% of the Stoxx 600's performance this year, is unlikely to provide the same level of juice as the previously dominant cyclical sectors like luxury firms.

The Emergence of New Market Drivers

While earnings estimates have generally been holding up so far for 2025, there are concerns that data surprises are more likely to hurt than help. As a result, investors are turning their attention to segments of the stock market that could take over market leadership if a recession is averted. Sectors like banks and utilities, which offer the prospect of rising dividends and earnings, as well as small and mid-cap stocks, are emerging as potential frontrunners in the race for the next wave of market leadership.