In a recent evaluation of infant car seats, Consumer Reports uncovered significant structural issues with two popular models. The investigation highlights the importance of stringent testing and safety standards for protecting young passengers. Although both seats meet federal regulations, their performance in more rigorous tests raises concerns among parents and safety experts. This report provides an overview of the findings and offers recommendations for safer alternatives.

Details of the Car Seat Safety Investigation

In the heart of autumn, when families prepare for road trips and daily commutes, Consumer Reports conducted a comprehensive analysis of infant car seats. During this meticulous examination, two particular models stood out for all the wrong reasons: the Diono LiteClik30 XT infant car seat and the Peg Perego Primo Viaggio 4-35 Urban Mobility baseless infant seat. Both products passed government-mandated safety tests but exhibited worrying structural weaknesses under more demanding conditions.

The tests simulated a crash at 35 miles per hour—a scenario slightly more intense than the federally required 30 mph. Unlike standard tests that use artificial setups, CR employed real vehicle components to better replicate actual crash dynamics. In these simulations, one impact was enough to reveal significant damage to the tested seats. This outcome is particularly alarming since real-world accidents often involve multiple impacts.

Diono responded by affirming its commitment to child safety and initiating a thorough investigation into the reported issues. Peg Perego, on the other hand, claimed that additional tests using CR’s protocol did not uncover any structural failures or safety concerns. Despite these findings, neither manufacturer has issued a recall.

For parents seeking safer options, CR recommends the Clek Liing with its innovative “load leg” support system, which enhances crash protection. Another top-rated choice is the Chicco KeyFit, praised for its ease of installation and affordability. Parents can also utilize CR’s free infant car seat finder tool to make informed decisions.

This investigation underscores the critical need for continuous improvement in safety standards. As a reader and future parent, it’s reassuring to know that organizations like Consumer Reports are vigilant in ensuring the safety of our youngest travelers. It serves as a reminder to always stay updated on product recalls and to choose car seats based on the latest safety ratings.