A much-awaited analysis by Consumer Reports has recently been released, presenting a composite ranking of car brands through a single road test score. In today's market flooded with car choices, consumers frequently find themselves bewildered by the plethora of options when purchasing a vehicle. Ranging from diverse makes and models to an extensive array of features and price points, the decision-making process can be quite intimidating. This is precisely where comprehensive ranking systems, such as those offered by Consumer Reports, play a crucial and invaluable role.

How Consumer Reports Crafts Their Road Test Score

Consumer Reports acquires 45 to 50 cars annually and subjects them to an extensive, multi-week program that encompasses more than 50 tests and evaluations. These assessments are carried out by automotive experts. The outcome is a single composite score that consolidates all the findings, accompanied by a detailed written road test accessible to members.“As the road-test score is an amalgamation of a particular model’s driving experience, taking into account power delivery, handling agility, braking performance, ride comfort, noise isolation, seat comfort, ease of using controls, and fuel economy (for non-EVs). For EVs, the score also considers range, charging time, and the simplicity of plugging and unplugging. Brands that offer well-rounded vehicles capable in multiple aspects are ranked highly,” explains Gabe Shenhar, the associate director of CR’s auto test program.

Consumer Reports' Brand Ranking Methodology

Consumer Reports ranks brands based on the average road-test score. This includes current models from their entire product portfolios that have undergone testing. Leading brands usually shine in a wide range of tests and exhibit consistent and strong performance across their lineup. Mid-tier brands often display more variation in performance among different car types or have mediocre test results. Brands at the bottom of the rankings clearly show deficits when compared to their competitors.

Top Ten Car Brands on the Road According to Consumer Reports

Securing the top position is BMW, with Audi closely following in second place and Porsche coming in third. As part of Consumer Reports' testing, each vehicle is driven for 2,000 miles before undergoing instrumented testing on their 6-mile track. This initial driving phase allows the engine, tires, and brakes to break in properly. Before the testing begins, the vehicles are meticulously inspected by mechanics who perform tasks like alignments to ensure the cars are in the best possible condition, guaranteeing the accuracy and relevance of the test results.The road-test score is ultimately combined with the results from reliability and owner satisfaction surveys, as well as ratings for safety features and crashworthiness, to generate an Overall Score. This provides a concise summary of a vehicle’s performance and attributes. If one has ever encountered a BMW, Audi, or Porsche driver, it becomes evident that these brands have some of the most loyal customers. Hence, it is no surprise that they achieve top podium results.

Asian-origin Brands' Dominance

Honda and Hyundai also made it to the top ten. The Japanese and South Korean brands have long been leaders in providing affordable cars without compromising on quality. Honda has established a reputation for reliability and durability, with popular models like the Civic and Accord offering a perfect blend of performance, fuel efficiency, and practicality.Hyundai, which was once regarded as a budget brand, has transformed into a strong competitor by offering stylish, well-equipped cars such as the Elantra and Sonata, along with impressive warranties. Both brands have garnered a loyal customer base by providing vehicles that combine excellent value with dependable performance, making them the top choices for consumers seeking quality at a reasonable price.Subaru, another Japanese brand, took fourth place, and the South Korean brand Kia came in sixth. Asian automakers have been at the forefront of adopting new technologies, ranging from hybrid and electric vehicles to advanced safety features, positioning themselves as leaders in the transition towards sustainable and intelligent driving. As the automotive landscape continues to evolve, these brands continue to set the benchmark for quality and performance, firmly establishing their dominance in the industry.