Are cows pickier than goats? Answers from innovative large-scale feeding experiments from 275 years ago

Sep 19, 2024 at 6:30 PM

Uncovering the Dietary Preferences of Livestock: Linnaeus' Groundbreaking 18th-Century Experiment

In a remarkable feat of scientific inquiry, the renowned 18th-century botanist Carl Linnaeus conducted a large-scale feeding experiment that explored the dietary preferences of various livestock species. This pioneering work, which predated the formal establishment of the field of ecology, has now been meticulously analyzed by a team of researchers, shedding new light on the feeding habits of animals centuries ago.

Unlocking the Secrets of Livestock Diets from the Past

Linnaeus' Ambitious Experiment

For his 18th-century thesis, Carl Linnaeus, the father of modern taxonomy, collected an impressive 643 different plant species and systematically fed them to horses, cows, pigs, sheep, and goats. The meticulous data he gathered, which included detailed observations on the animals' feeding behaviors, remained largely untouched for over two centuries until a team of researchers from Uppsala University decided to delve into this treasure trove of historical information.

Rediscovering a Pioneering Ecological Study

Linnaeus' work, known as the "Pan Svecicus," was a groundbreaking endeavor that predated the formal establishment of the field of ecology in the late 19th century. By today's standards, the scale of this experiment was truly remarkable, involving a vast array of plant species and a diverse range of livestock. Håkan Rydin, a Professor of Plant Ecology at Uppsala University and one of the researchers involved in the analysis, notes that this study may have been "the first experiment in what would only later become the subject of ecology."

Uncovering the Data's Hidden Insights

The researchers faced the challenge of deciphering Linnaeus' meticulous records, which included references to his own comprehensive list of Swedish flora, the "Flora Svecica." This allowed them to identify the specific plant species involved in the experiments, a crucial step in unlocking the data's full potential. Rydin and his team meticulously compiled and analyzed the findings, revealing a wealth of insights into the dietary preferences of the various livestock species.

Surprising Revelations About Livestock Feeding Habits

The analysis of Linnaeus' data yielded some unexpected findings. Contrary to popular belief, the animals were not particularly adept at avoiding toxic plants, with cows and horses being the best at this task. Pigs, being omnivores, were the most selective eaters, consuming only 32% of the 204 plant species tested. In contrast, goats were the least selective, consuming 85% of the plant species.

The Enduring Legacy of Linnaeus' Work

Linnaeus' pioneering work laid the groundwork for future scientists to explore the complex relationships between plants and animals. Rydin emphasizes the significance of Linnaeus' meticulous documentation, noting that if this experiment had been conducted in more recent times, the raw data might not have been preserved. The researchers' ability to analyze this historical data is a testament to Linnaeus' foresight and the enduring value of his contributions to the scientific community.

Implications for Modern Livestock Management

The insights gleaned from Linnaeus' 18th-century experiment have the potential to inform modern livestock management practices. Understanding the dietary preferences and feeding behaviors of different livestock species can help farmers and ranchers optimize their pasture management, improve animal health, and enhance the sustainability of their operations. This rediscovered treasure trove of historical data serves as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners alike, offering a unique window into the past that can shape the future of livestock management.