Over the past two decades, the Academy Awards have been a subject of controversy and criticism. The author of this piece has chosen to boycott the Oscars for several years, citing the institution's tendency to reward mediocrity and overlook true artistic merit. This critique spans from 2001 to 2024, highlighting specific instances where the Academy made questionable choices. Each year, the author points out films that should have won Best Picture and laments the omission of deserving yet overlooked works. This pattern of misjudgment raises questions about the integrity and relevance of the Academy in recognizing cinematic excellence.

A Comprehensive Look at the Academy's Missteps

In the early 2000s, Robert Altman's Gosford Park was overshadowed by Ron Howard's A Beautiful Mind, despite its nuanced exploration of class dynamics. Fast forward to 2003, Sofia Coppola's Lost in Translation lost to The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, a film that, while popular, lacked the subtlety and depth of Coppola's work. The year 2005 saw a particularly egregious oversight when Brokeback Mountain lost to Crash, a decision that continues to be debated in Hollywood circles.

As the decade progressed, the trend continued. In 2008, Gus van Sant's Milk was overshadowed by Danny Boyle's Slumdog Millionaire. The expansion of Best Picture nominees in 2009 led to The Hurt Locker winning over Avatar, a choice that seemed more about critical acclaim than genuine artistic achievement. Quentin Tarantino's Inglourious Basterds deserved recognition but was overlooked. Similarly, Wes Anderson's The Grand Budapest Hotel in 2014 and Paul Thomas Anderson's Phantom Thread in 2017 were both snubbed in favor of less compelling films.

The 2020s brought new challenges, with streaming services like Netflix challenging traditional studio dominance. Alfonso Cuarón's Roma faced resistance due to its release platform, despite its undeniable quality. In 2021, Licorice Pizza showcased the brilliance of Paul Thomas Anderson, yet it was overshadowed by the more conventional CODA. Finally, in 2024, Sean Baker's Anora emerged as a frontrunner, offering a refreshing change from the predictable Oscar bait.

Reflections on the Academy's Role

The Academy Awards are meant to celebrate the best in cinema, yet they often fall short of this goal. The recurring pattern of overlooking innovative and daring films in favor of safe, crowd-pleasing choices reflects a deeper issue within the industry. While some may argue that the Oscars serve as a reflection of public taste, it is clear that the Academy's decisions do not always align with true artistic merit. This discrepancy invites us to reconsider the role of awards in shaping our understanding of great cinema. Perhaps the future will bring reforms that prioritize creativity and originality over commercial success and tradition.