For the 2025 Awards, a significant reorganisation has taken place. In the mid-sized family vehicle category, the distinction between 'car' and 'SUV' has become extremely blurred, rendering it almost meaningless. As a result, these vehicle types have been grouped together. Instead, medium cars have been divided into mainstream and premium categories, as this better aligns with how real-world car buyers approach their next vehicle purchase. The badge and feature list play a more crucial role than the body style. Interestingly, customers are predominantly choosing SUV-style cars over conventional hatchback/saloon/estate models, despite the fact that they offer no more practicality or space and have zero off-roading capabilities.

Redefining Mid-sized Family Vehicle Categories for 2025 Awards

Grouping of Mid-sized Vehicles

The blurring of the line between 'car' and 'SUV' in the mid-sized family vehicle segment has led to a strategic decision. By grouping them together, the awards organisers aim to provide a more comprehensive and relevant assessment. This change reflects the evolving preferences of car buyers who are increasingly drawn to SUV-style vehicles without the added practicality or space.

It is a significant shift that challenges the traditional categorisation and forces us to reevaluate the importance of body style in the mid-sized vehicle market.

This reorganisation also sets the stage for a more focused evaluation of the vehicles based on other factors such as badge and feature list.

Separation of Medium Cars into Mainstream and Premium

The separation of medium cars into mainstream and premium categories is a crucial aspect of the 2025 Awards reorganisation. This distinction better reflects the real-world preferences of car buyers who look for specific features and qualities in their next vehicle.

While the badge and feature list have become more important than the body style, it is interesting to note the overwhelming choice of SUV-style cars by customers.

This separation allows for a more detailed assessment of the different market segments and helps identify the best vehicles in each category.

Best New Premium Medium Car and Class Champion: Porsche Macan Electric (79%)

It has been over 20 years since Porsche first ventured beyond its sports car boundaries with the Cayenne. Over the past two decades, the company has steadily expanded its model range to cater to a wider audience of premium car buyers who do not require or desire a two-seat (or two-and-a-bit seats) sports car. The new Macan Electric is Porsche's second electric offering following the highly regarded Taycan.

Reviewers have been highly enthusiastic about the driving dynamics of the Porsche Macan Electric. Every model has received rave reviews, with praise pouring in for its performance.

Porsche has utilised the fundamental differences of an EV to create a better car rather than a mere alternative. The Macan Electric sets a new premium benchmark for the entire industry to aspire to.

Class Champion, Petrol/Diesel: BMW 3 Series (84%)

Although the current BMW 3 Series is approaching retirement age, it remains the mid-size car that reviewers rate highest for those who prefer an internal combustion engine. The 3 Series has long been the dynamic benchmark for small-to-medium saloons, and the current model matches the refinement of even the best EVs.

For the past three years, the BMW 3 Series has held the petrol/diesel class champion title and continues to do so comfortably this year.

Its enduring popularity and performance make it a standout in the mid-sized car segment, especially for those who value traditional powertrains.

The Car Expert Awards 2025 – All the Category Winners

The Car Expert Awards 2025 recognise both the best new models launched in the last 12 months and the overall best cars in each category. Newest does not always mean best, and these awards aim to showcase the true excellence in the automotive industry.

Each category winner represents a unique combination of features, performance, and value, providing car buyers with a comprehensive guide to the best options available.

The 2025 Awards serve as a benchmark for the automotive industry and highlight the continuous evolution and innovation in vehicle design and technology.