In a recent podcast episode featuring Patrick Schmitt MW and db Bordeaux correspondent Colin Hay, listeners were treated to an in-depth analysis of the standout wines from the 2024 harvest. Despite challenging growing conditions that resulted in a steep quality pyramid, with some wines excelling while others fell short, several estates managed to produce extraordinary vintages. From Montrose's crystalline purity to the brilliance of Gruaud Larose, this year's harvest tells a story of resilience and success.
In the heart of the Medoc region, during a season marked by demanding weather patterns, one estate stood out above all others: Château Montrose. This second growth property delivered a wine so exquisite that it transcended its vintage origins. Its beauty was matched only by the remarkable performances of Gruaud Larose in St Julien and Cos d’Estournel in St Estephe. Further south, in Margaux, Palmer emerged as another beacon of success amidst the trials faced by winemakers that year.
Among the first growths, Mouton and Lafite shone particularly brightly, though Latour's minuscule yields made their achievement even more noteworthy. Turning to the Right Bank, Pomerol saw triumphs at Lafleur and Le Pin, joined by the stunning Eglise Clinet. However, it was in St Emilion where surprises truly unfolded. Peter Sisseck's Château Rocheyron coalesced with Bélair-Monange to form the pinnacle of excellence within this appellation, surpassing even Cheval Blanc and Figeac in quality.
Colin Hay emphasized that these exceptional wines are not merely compensations for tougher conditions; they stand shoulder-to-shoulder with any great vintage produced by these esteemed estates.
From a journalist's perspective, this tale of triumph amid adversity serves as a powerful reminder of the dedication and skill required in winemaking. It highlights how certain estates can rise above nature’s challenges through careful cultivation and meticulous craftsmanship, producing masterpieces that defy expectations. As we look forward to future campaigns and releases, this narrative reinforces our appreciation for the artistry behind each bottle crafted under such trying circumstances.